opal AT lists.psi.ch
Subject: The OPAL Discussion Forum
List archive
- From: Yi-Nong Rao <raoyn AT triumf.ca>
- To: Andreas Adelmann <andreas.adelmann AT psi.ch>
- Cc: Norman Huang <norman-huang AT hotmail.com>, Rick Bartman <krab AT triumf.ca>, Thomas Planche <tplanche AT triumf.ca>, opal AT lists.psi.ch
- Subject: [Opal] Re: SBend Results and Questions
- Date: Thu, 17 Nov 2011 17:13:36 -0800
- List-archive: <https://lists.web.psi.ch/pipermail/opal/>
- List-id: The OPAL Discussion Forum <opal.lists.psi.ch>
Andreas,
Further to Norman's e-mail, I want to make it clearer as to what the issue is.
What he did was a simple test to OPAL: track a single particle through a 90 degrees
magnetic S-bender with the fringe field turned off. The initial X is -0.004m while initial
PX is 0. (Initial means at the entrance of the magnet.) The X,PX values were recorded
at each step of the numerical integration up to the exit of the magnet. As a result of
OPAL tracking, X vs S appears to a cosine curve as expected (please look at Page 3 of
Norman's summary "SBEND-results.pdf"), while PX vs S shows funny numbers near
zero instead of a sine curve (see Page 7). I don't understand this. We cannot figure out
why from your source code.
It makes no sense to track multiple particles if a single particle tracking does not give
correct result. We may have misunderstood something. Could you take a careful look at
Norman's input and output files and help us out?
Thanks in advance.
Yi-Nong
Norman Huang wrote:
Yi-Nong and I do not know how to interpret these SBEND results. Please take a look at my test cases summary. Attached are the OPAL input file (qf.in), Enge coefficient file (FAND1.T7), single particle tracking data (particleInfo_Fringe.txt, particleInfo_NoFringe.txt)
The 12 columns for the particleInfo files are:
Bx By Bz X_ref Y_ref Z_ref Px Py Pz X_local Y_local Z_local
Regards
Norman
- [Opal] SBend Results and Questions, Norman Huang, 11/18/2011
- [Opal] Re: SBend Results and Questions, Yi-Nong Rao, 11/18/2011
- [Opal] Re: SBend Results and Questions, raoyn, 11/18/2011
- Re: [Opal] SBend Results and Questions, Steve Russell, 11/24/2011
- [Opal] Re: SBend Results and Questions, Yi-Nong Rao, 11/18/2011
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19.